合气道遇到跆拳道的怎么办

莉

这好像不是化圆大或是化圆小的问题，很多高段师范的waza都是非常小的

Aiki-age

Robert Spear＆Donald J. Burns

全美仅有的两位七段（全美大韩合气道协会提供），royalchan兄说得那位双八段的高人，我可以请教一下大名吗？照您这么说，他的＂大韩合气道＂八段应该是＂合气会＂颁发的了？＂合气会＂八段的老师也不多吧？！真是一位奇人．

我的韩国老师是大韩合气道三段，教了我们那么长时间，最多有点＂手解＂像＂合气道＂．训练是以击打，摔投和关节技构成的，其中击打为主．韩国道馆的观摩以及大量高段师范写的资料（老师从韩国带回来的）说明，在韩国也是这么练的．

我不明白，你说的Hapkido是什么样子．但韩国人是绝对不承认大韩合气道与Aikido是一样的．在任何一本书的＂The　History　Of　Hapkido＂里，都说它起源于新罗王朝．当然，这种说法很不可靠．但，Hapkido＝Aikido的说法也很荒谬．

royalchan

To Aiki-age: Sorry I can not type in Chinese here.

Thanks a lot for your reply. My master's name is Hosoo Hwang. http://www.hwangsmas.com/Welcome.htm Sorry I really don't know whether he is associated with "dahanheqidao" or "heqihui". Maybe because I am only a yellow belt he explained very simple to me, yet I still think the most basic is always the most essential part. I agree that Hapkido is not equal to Aikido, and Koreans would say that Hapkido roots from ancient Korea (and I believe that's because it actually has a inseparable part of Taekwondo), and just as you said we DO do a lot of punches and kicks (just like Taekwondo) and throws, but I still think that you have to agree they belong to the same category. Thanks.

By the way, I am a little surprised that you know I live in America.^_^

莉

你们是不是越来越偏离主题了吧。既然偏离了主题，那么我就不客气关贴了，如果有什么意见请向我或是大版主提出谢谢